The Beanie Baby Bubble of ’99

Two decades ago, we fought, trampled, and even killed each other over little sacks of beans. Today, we realize how stupid it all was — but our behavior hasn’t changed.

May 19, 2018

 

O

n November 5, 1999, Frances and Harold Mountain sat crouched on the floor of a Las Vegas divorce courtroom, divvying up their most valued asset.

It wasn’t the house. It wasn’t the car. It wasn’t the computer, the appliances, the jewelry, the books, or the CDs. The hotly contested asset at hand was their Beanie Baby collection.

“Spread them out on the floor,” ordered the judge, “and I’ll have [you] pick one each until they’re all gone.” Frances made a beeline for Maple the Bear.

At the time, the little bean-filled sacks were more than a toy: they were an investment vehicle. Fueled by a rabid collectors’ market, Ty Inc. had just exceeded $1B in annual sales. Certain “retired” characters were going for as much as $13k on the resale market — 3,000x their original price.

Beanie baby court

Frances and Harold Mountain, recently divorced, duke it out over their Beanie Baby collection in court (Associated Press; 1999)

Unbeknownst to the hapless rubes above, it was all about to come crashing down.

How did one man convince the world that these glorified stuffed animals were worth their weight in gold? The answer is tied to our very human nature — and it helps explain why we continually fall victim to speculative bubbles.

Phase 1: The creation of a mania

 

Ty Warner got his start as a sales rep at Dakin Toy Company, then the world’s largest manufacturer of plush toys, in the early 1970s.

He quickly became the Dakin’s top salesman, aided in part by his marketing antics: When meeting with clients, he’d build intrigue by emerging from a white Rolls-Royce, festooned with a full-length fur coat and a cane.

In 1986, Warner had a crazy idea that changed the course of his life.

At the time, most plush toys were filled with stiff, rigid cotton. Warner decided that plastic pellets (or, as he later called them, “beans”) would allow for more flexible, “realistic” toys.

He began to work on his idea on the side — but when Dankin found out, he was promptly fired. So, Warner decided to launch his own toy company in a suburb outside of Chicago. He dubbed it “Ty Inc.”

Initially, buyers told Warner his toys were flimsy pieces of crap. “Everyone called them roadkill,” he later said. “They didn’t get it.”

But behind the scenes, Warner had a plan up his fur-lined sleeve — and Beanie Babies were about to spark a worldwide mania.

Ty Warner quote

Ty Warner poses in 1996 (People Magazine; photo edit by The Hustle)

Warner was a master manipulator of supply and demand, and he made a series of calculated decisions that drove the market to madness.

First, he decided to price Beanie Babies at $5 a pop — accessible enough for anyone to get in on the trend. More importantly, he only sold them to small specialty shops and toy stores rather than giant chains, and limited the number they could purchase.

Meanwhile, he engineered an incredibly tight-lipped culture at Ty Inc.: there was a “total information blackout” on things like how many ‘Patti the Platypus’ toys would be sold, or which stores would carry ‘Baldy the Eagle.’

This created a certain mysticism around the product: Buyers could never find the whole collection in one place, and toys always seemed like they were sold out at each location.

But, his biggest stroke of genius came in 1995, when he surmised that if he “retired” certain Beanie Babies after a short period of time, it would create an illusion of scarcity (in reality, Ty was pumping out millions of them in overseas factories).

After being retired, Beanie Babies that sold for $5 would go for $15-20 — and on the internet, some sold for as much as $13k.

Phase 2: Trampled children, smuggling rings, and murder

 

In the midst of this perceived “shortage,” collectors launched an all-out Beanie Baby warfare. Among the more notable instances:

  • At a market in Connecticut, fanatical collectors trampled children to get their hands on the retired tie-dye “Garcia” bear.
  • A 77-year-old Chicago man dubbed the “Beanie Baby Bandit” stole 1.2k of the toys and hoarded them in a storage locker.
  • At the border, Beanie Baby smuggling rings ran rampant (“People are smuggling [them] in similar places where they hide drugs,” an agent told the Seattle Times).
  • A West Virginia man shot and killed a 63-year-old security guard over a dispute involving “several hundred dollars’ worth” of Beanie Babies.

“He didn’t want the cash register — all he wanted was the Beanie Babies,” said a Los Angeles store clerk who was robbed at gunpoint for 40 bears. “With the amount of money these things are getting on the market, it was bound to happen sometime.”

Beanie baby mob

Beanie Baby enthusiasts form a mob at a UK gift shop in the late ‘90s (Hyoung Chang/Getty Images)

During a 1997 promotion with McDonald’s, Ty Inc. sold 100m “Tennie Beanies” in just 10 days. Across the country, grown men wrestled over toys with names like “Pinky the Flamingo” and “Seamore the Seal.” There were fistfights, theft rings, and temper tantrums.

This mania was great news for Ty, Inc.: By 1998, the company was raking in more than $1B per year in profit. At a holiday party that same year, Warner, a billionaire in his own right, stood before a room of 250 of his employees and shouted, “I’ve never seen so many millionaires in my life!”

But it was all about to come crashing down…

Phase 3: The Beanie Baby bubble pops

 

One night in 1999, Ty announced the retirement of several Beanie Babies… and nothing happened. No market swell. No value increase. Nothing.

It was the beginning of the end. Collectors panicked and took to eBay to sell off huge swaths of the toys, flooding the market with a massive surplus of Beanie Babies. Their value, which was contingent on the illusion of scarcity, plummeted.

In a desperate bid to save a sinking ship, Ty announced that all Beanie Babies would go out of production at the end of 1999. It didn’t work.

Beanie Baby prices

Beanie Baby prices have declined by more than 98% since the late ‘90s (The Hustle)

According to Zac Bissonnette, author of “The Great Beanie Baby Bubble,” sales declined by more than 90% — and by the early 2000s, most Beanie Babies were worth just 1% of their original sale price.

BuyingBeanies.com and other bulk purchasing sites sprang up, offering 20 to 40 cents per toy. Once proudly displayed in shop windows, they were sold by the boxful to claw machine operators and county fair carnies.

Hoards of hopeful Beanie flippers flocked to toy resellers, hoping to cash in their “rare” Princess Diana bears, but they only managed to get a few bucks. “They think [the bears] are worth a quarter of a million dollars,” one toy buyer said. “No one’s ever trying to buy them, only sell them.”

The bubble popped, and with it, some big bettors had their little Ty hearts broken.

Phase 4: The family who lost $100k

 

At the height of the Beanie Baby boom, gurus emerged, offering financial insights and words of wisdom to hopeful collectors.

Don West, a former wrestling hype man, appeared on Beanie Baby infomercials admonishing viewers they shouldn’t “let the opportunity of a lifetime” slip through their fingers.

Venerable publications like Mary Beth’s Beanie World sold 650k copies per month, and encouraged readers to use the toys as an “investment strategy,” with topics like “How To You Protect An Investment That Increases By 8,400%.”

“Simply putting away five or ten of each and every new Beanie Baby in super mint condition isn’t a bad idea,” suggested the Beanie Baby Handbook, in 1998.

Unfortunately, it was — and some people lost a lot of money.

Beanie baby man

Chris Robinson, Sr. spent over $100k on Beanie Babies over 5 years (screenshot via “Bankrupt By Beanies” by Chris Robinson)

Chris Robinson Sr., an ex-actor from California, spent more than $100k on 20k Beanie Babies between 1994 and 1999, with the idea that the toys would appreciate and one day fund college tuition for his 5 children.

“He described it as kind of like a drug addiction,” his son, who later made a short documentary titled “Bankrupt By Beanies,” told Marketplace.

He wasn’t the only one: across America, thousands of hard-core Beanie collectors — including a New York woman who dumped her $12k life savings into the toys — watched their “fortunes” dwindle

“It’s better than gambling or drugs, right?’’ one man said of his family’s hobby in 1999, in the midst of the collapse. “And we have it under control now. We only spend about $500 a month on Beanies.”

But a question remains: How did otherwise rational, fully-functioning adults convince themselves that a $5 bean bag would one day pay for a college education? And why did they buy into an ephemeral trend, even when it was dying right before their eyes?

The psychology of a bubble

 

All bubbles — from 1637’s tulip mania, to the first dot.com crash, to Beanie Babies — go through 4 major stages:

Beanie Baby bubble

Beanie Babies followed a familiar trajectory (The Hustle)

Why do we repeatedly fall into the same trap?

According to economists David Tuckett and Richard Taffler, we often view a hot new financial opportunity as a “phantastic object,” or an unconscious representation of something that fulfills our wildest desires.

These objects are “exciting and transformational.” They appear to “break the usual rules of life and turn aspects of ‘normal’ reality on its head.” They promise something far departed from the market’s typical behavior.

During a bubble, we formulate a “collective hallucination” of prosperity, and fall victim to groupthink, a phenomenon where “a significant chunk of society feverishly buys into a shared dream” and ignores reality.

Eventually, we come to realize that a $5 bear full of beans is not a sound investment but, in fact, a $5 bear full of f*cking beans, and we self-correct.

Some economists argue this resonates in today’s market.

“Beanie Babies and Bitcoin share a lot of similarities,” says Taffler, a professor of finance at Warwick Business School.

Cryptocurrencies, like Beanie Babies, promise a fruitful alternative to classical investments. They are released in limited quantities. Gurus extol their virtues, and in online communities, “HODLers” convince each other that they’re impervious to the wild fluctuations of a volatile market.

But when a bubble finally pops, says Taffler, “most of us get burned.”

Ty Warner

Ty Warner in 1996 (Kevin Horan/Corbis)

There was one person who emerged handsomely from the Beanie Baby bubble: Ty Warner.

Aside from getting caught secretly hoarding $107m of his Beanie Baby riches in an offshore Swiss bank account, Warner has kept a low profile over the years — but he’s quietly amassed a fortune the size of Djibouti’s GDP.

Today, the 73-year-old Beanie Baby inventor touts an estimated net worth of $2.7B, good for the 887th richest person in the world. He owns a fleet of luxury cars, a $153m estate, $41m worth of rare art, and the Four Seasons Hotel in New York, where you can rent the “Ty Warner Penthouse” for $50k per night.

Years ago, at the height of his success, Warner told a fellow exec that he could “put the Ty Heart on manure and [people would] buy it.”

Turns out, he was right.

Share and discuss



Sign up here for our daily news email to get all the non-political news you never knew you needed. All it takes is 5 minutes and BOOM, you're smarter.

Your news, our way.
For a daily email you'll actually want to read
Weekdays at 9am Pacific